Ok, so maybe it's not timely in the middle of the summer, but my last post about Emmy snubs got me thinking about the Oscars.
The Emmys changed their voting process this year and is getting a lot of heat for what a failure it was (with all of the odd nominations and omissions).
I think, however, that it IS time for the Oscars to change something. For years and years, good comedies and comedic performances have gotten the shaft from Oscar in favor of dramatic performances. If the Academy is going to be snooty about recognizing them as high-quality performances, then it's time to go ahead and add separate categories for Best Movie - Comedy, Best Actor - Comedy, etc, breaking them out like the Emmys and Golden Globes do.
Here is the start of a list I made off the top of my head of recent comedic performances that were outstanding and deserved to be recognized as such by the Academy. Why is a great performance that makes someone laugh inferior to a performance that makes someone cry? It shouldn't be.
CHEVY CHASE - Clark Griswold in "Vacation" (1983)Arguably, one of the best characters in movie history. Here are the 5 nominees for Best Actor that year - you tell me Chevy wasn't shafted! -
Bob Duvall (Tender Mercies), Tom Courtenay (The Dresser)
Albert Finney (The Dresser), Michael Cain (Educating Rita)
Tom Conti (Reuben, Reuben)
MIKE MYERS - Austin Powers/Dr. Evil in "Austin Powers" (1997)One Word: "Shhh!"
STEVE MARTIN - Navin R. Johnson, et al. in "The Jerk" (1979)Okay, so he would have gone up against Dustin Hoffman, Al Pacino and Jack Lemmon that year... tough competition. And there was no way the Academy was going to unstuff it for this guy back then. No way. Lost cause. But worthy, nonetheless.
TED KNIGHT - Judge Smails in "Caddyshack" (1980)This one would have been a "Supporting Actor" candidate and I'd argue it 'til the cows come home. Winner that year? Timothy Hutton for "Ordinary People." Exactly. Other memorable nominated performances included Jason Robards in "Melvin & Howard" and Michael O'Keefe in "The Great Santini." Puh-lease. All I can say to those chumps is, "How about a Fresca?"